Health and Nutrition

Holistic weight reduction - Part12 - The Arithmetic of Weight Reduction


While most dietitians and nutritionists talk about the energy intake requirements of an average American male or female, no guru of weight reduction instructs his disciples on how to figure out the daily energy expenditure of a particular individual. Calculations of ‘appropriate’ energy intake based on the current weight of the individual are highly misleading and significantly overestimates the need of required energy intake. Since balancing energy intake with the energy expenditure of the body is the only sound way for safe and sustained weight reduction, an accurate and individualized energy expenditure calculation is mandatory. Impossible as this may seem in the face of fluctuations of energy expenditure from day to day, an effective average daily expenditure can be calculated if one is prepared to discipline oneself to the same extent that one does to balance a checkbook and can be meticulous about documenting energy intake! If death and taxes are the inevitable realities of human life, the ability to calculate the average daily energy expenditure is the essential that one must master to understand an effective and sensible approach to the task of fat weight reduction.

  • Calculation of average daily energy expenditure
  • These simple calculations are made on the basis of the three fundamental facts already mentioned in chapter 2. To recapitulate they are:
  • a. When energy expenditure equals energy intake, there is no gain in adipose tissue weight.
  • b. One pound of neutral fat stores 4100 Calories (456 grams of fat x 9 calories per gram)
  • c. To lose one pound of body fat per week, there must be a caloric deficit of 600 Calories between daily energy intake and output: to express it in another way, energy expenditure must be greater than energy intake by 600 Calories daily.
  • We further make two minor assumptions to simplify the calculations and make it within the mental grasp of all.
  • 1. In a healthy body the wave like fluctuations in body fluid weight reaches its lowest level once every three weeks for adult males and post-menopausal women due to the intermittent excretion of water from the body. For women within reproductive years, the lowest level is reached once every four weeks (or the duration of their menstrual cycle lengths) at the end of each period. Drugs, such as estrogens, diuretics, steroids etc negate this assumption.
  • 2. There is no appreciable gain or loss within a 3-4 week period in the weight of the organs, muscles and skeletal tissues of the body. This of course is true only if tissue-wasting diseases such as an overactive thyroid gland, cancer, AIDS, etc are absent and drugs which affect the weight of tissues are not being used.
  • There are only three simple steps involved in the calculation of fairly accurate average daily energy expenditure.

    STEP 1:
    Weigh oneself using a reliable scale at the beginning of a 3-week period (in the case of males and post-menopausal women) or on the last day of the menstrual period (in the case of women in the reproductive years). A scale similar to the one in a physician’s office is more reliable than most of the scales available in the market. The weighing must be undertaken in the morning after voiding and bowel movement and before breakfast. Make a note of the weight.

    STEP 2:
    For the next three or four weeks, depending on one’s gender and state in life (male, post menopausal woman, menstruating female) and using a calorie counter available at most health food stores write down in a diary or a notebook the caloric content of any food or drink that goes across your lips. Keep the usual diet during this time of caloric count and continue with the usual physical activities. At the end of each day add up all the Calories consumed that day. At the end of the three or four weeks add up all the Calories consumed during that period.

    STEP 3:
    Weigh oneself again at the end of the duration of the collection of data in the same manner as in Step 1 and note it down.

    Let WB denote the weight at the beginning and WE be the weight at the end of the test duration. Let TC be the total Calories consumed and let TE be the total amount of Calories expended during the same period. Then simple arithmetic will show that:

  • (i) When WB= WE, the individual has remained the same weight, or energy expenditure equaled energy consumed and hence TE must equal TC
  • (ii) When WB > WE , the individual has lost weight or energy expenditure was greater than energy consumed and hence (WB - WE ) x 4100 = TE - TC
  • (iii) When WE > WB, the individual has gained weight or energy consumed was greater than energy expended and hence (WE - WB) x 4100 = TC - TE,
  • The value of TE can be calculated from one of these equations depending on which of the three findings (i) to (iii) is applicable to the individual, since the values of WB, WE, and TC are known. The value of TE divided by the number of days for which the caloric count was undertaken is the average daily number of Calories expended by the individual.

    Example One:
    John, a laborer weighed 210 pounds at the beginning and weighed 210 pounds at the end of 3 weeks. During that period of time he consumed 60,825 Calories. Since there was no weight gain, he must have expended all the calories present in the food intake. So his average daily caloric expenditure is 60, 825 divided by 21 = 2,896 Calories.

    Example Two:
    Cindy, who is a menstruating female weighed 124 pounds at the beginning and at the end of 4 weeks (or menstrual cycle length) weighed 122 pounds. During the 4-week duration, she consumed 41, 640 Calories. Since she lost two pounds, she expended more calories than she consumed and this excess amount is obtained by multiplying weight loss by 4100, giving a figure of 8200. So Cindy expended 41,640 + 8200 = 51,840 Calories during the 28 day interval. Her average daily caloric expenditure therefore is 51,840 divided by 28 = 1,851 Calories.

    Example Three:
    Susan, who is a post-menopausal woman not taking estrogen replacement therapy weighed 150 pounds at the beginning of the caloric count and 3 weeks later was surprised to find that she had gained 3 pounds. Her energy intake added up to a total of 46,280 Calories. Since she gained 3 pounds, she converted into adipose tissue 3 x 4100 =12,300 Calories, indicating that she expended only 46,280 - 12,300 = 35,920 Calories. 35,920 divided by 21 = 1710 is her average caloric expenditure.

    About the Author : Abe Kurien MD, is a proponent of holistic medicine. He writes profusely on subjects of Weight reduction. His enlightening articles can be found on the smatix weight reduction section : Health and Nutrition Guide


    MORE RESOURCES:

    Obesity Linked to Worse Fibromyalgia Symptoms (HealthDay)
    HealthDay - WEDNESDAY, Feb. 8 (HealthDay News) -- Obese people are not only at greater risk for fibromyalgia, they are likely to experience more severe symptoms of the condition, such as chronic pain, fatigue, sleep disturbance and mood disorders, according to a new study.
    Even for the Overweight, Exercise Helps the Heart (HealthDay)
    HealthDay - TUESDAY, Feb. 7 (HealthDay News) -- Getting and staying physically fit might help fend off heart disease even if you've put on a few pounds, new research suggests.
    Behavior programs may cut child obesity risk (Reuters)
    Reuters - Programs that teach parenting skills early on may help prevent obesity in poor U.S. kids, a study published Monday suggests.
    Study: Family Intervention, Parent Education Reduce Childhood Obesity (ContributorNetwork)
    ContributorNetwork - A study published in the February issue of Pediatrics shows family intervention aimed at improving parenting skills reduced behavior problems in kids and obesity and associated health problems. One-third of Americans, including children ages 2 to 17, are overweight or obese, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention statistics. Here are details about parent-child interventions.
    Orexigen, FDA agree on trial design for obesity drug (Reuters)
    Reuters - Orexigen Therapeutics Inc said it reached an agreement with U.S. health regulators on the design of a heart-safety trial required for the approval of its experimental obesity drug.
    Prosecutors: Ind. woman left decomposing in chair (AP)
    AP - A southeastern Indiana woman has been charged after prosecutors say she left her morbidly obese sister alive and decomposing in a chair for three weeks.
    Obesity Could Be Infectious (LiveScience.com)
    LiveScience.com - We've heard obesity can be "spread" between friends when we copy each other's eating habits, but a new study in mice suggests obesity could actually be infectious.
    Childhood Obesity May Cause Future Heart Disease Epidemic (ContributorNetwork)
    ContributorNetwork - "A coming epidemic" is how pediatric cardiologists are describing the impending problems from high rates of juvenile obesity, reports The Missourian. Here are details for parents about overweight kids, heart disease and other concomitant health issues.
    FDA panel to discuss Arena obesity drug in 2nd quarter (Reuters)
    Reuters - An FDA advisory committee will meet in the second quarter to discuss Arena Pharmaceutical Inc's experimental obesity drug following the company's recent resubmission of an application seeking its approval, Arena said on Wednesday.
    Mommy Bloggers' Flawed Take on Anti-Obesity Ads (ContributorNetwork)
    ContributorNetwork - COMMENTARY | According to HLN, the newest and most vocal critics of Children's Healthcare of Atlanta's anti-obesity ad campaign are a group known as "mommy bloggers." These angry mothers feel the controversial ads, which depict obese children as unhappy and suffering from medical maladies, do more harm than good by shaming children instead of encouraging them. Critics argue that shaming tactics only lead to greater tendencies to overeat and can lead to higher numbers of eating disorders.
    When Mom-to-Be's Overweight and Smokes, Risk for Birth Defects Rises (HealthDay)
    HealthDay - TUESDAY, Jan. 31 (HealthDay News) -- Women who are both overweight and smoke during pregnancy could damage their baby's developing heart, a new study warns.
    Weight loss may prevent leaky bladder in diabetes (Reuters)
    Reuters - Overweight women with diabetes may be able to cut their risk of urine leakage if they shed some pounds, a new study suggests.
    "Biggest Loser" host, dog Winky battle pet obesity (Reuters)
    Reuters - Alison Sweeney, host of the NBC network's weight loss TV series "The Biggest Loser," has worked with the show's contestants since 2007, supporting them as they drop pounds and learn to lead a healthier way of life.
    Calories count, but source doesn't matter: study (Reuters)
    Reuters - People trying to lose weight may swear by specific diet plans calling for strict proportions of fat, carbs and protein, but where the calories come from may not matter as much as simply cutting back on them, according to a study.
    Long Shifts May Raise Some Nurses' Odds for Obesity (HealthDay)
    HealthDay - WEDNESDAY, Jan. 25 (HealthDay News) -- Nurses who work long hours and have less physically demanding jobs are much more likely to be obese than other nurses, according to a new study.
    Device makers urge coverage of weight-loss surgery (Reuters)
    Reuters - Device manufacturers are pushing the government and health insurers to cover weight-loss surgery, an effort that could give millions more obese Americans access to the treatments.
    Parents Are Key in Helping Obese Kids Lose Weight, AHA Says (ContributorNetwork)
    ContributorNetwork - The key to combating juvenile obesity lies with parents, the American Heart Association says. The AHA released a scientific statement in its most recent issue of "Circulation" journal. Here are tips for parents to curb weight problems in kids, based on that report.
    Hip Fracture Patients Often Have Other Health Problems (HealthDay)
    HealthDay - MONDAY, Jan. 23 (HealthDay News) -- Weight loss and malnutrition are among the medical conditions that increase treatment costs and the length of hospital stays for older adults with hip fractures, a new study finds.
    Parents May Hold Key to Treating Kids' Obesity (HealthDay)
    HealthDay - MONDAY, Jan. 23 (HealthDay News) -- Parents and caregivers should be involved in treatment programs for obese children and should lead by example, praise children's progress and use setbacks as learning opportunities, experts say.
    Overweight linked to acne in teen girls (Reuters)
    Reuters - Overweight girls in their late teens were twice as likely as their normal-weight peers to report having a lot of acne in a large new survey of Norwegian teenagers that did not find the same link in boys.
    home |       site map |      Disclaimer |       Privacy Policy
    © 2006